The Star Wars sequel trilogy (The Force Awakens, The Last Jedi, and The Rise of Skywalker) has generated significant discussion regarding its fan reception, with opinions varying widely on its storytelling choices and overall place within the long-running saga. Despite the ongoing debate, Brian Herring, the actor and puppeteer who helped bring the droid BB-8 to life on screen, offers a perspective that frames the trilogy’s reception in a broader historical context within the franchise.
“I think the sequels are no more polarising than the prequels were when they came out,” Herring explained, as reported by Gamereactor. He went on to elaborate that much of the backlash stems from generational differences in how audiences experience and discuss new entries in the beloved franchise, especially in the age of social media.
All the people who are upset about the sequels are too young to remember how upset the people when the original ones came out were, except they now have the internet. If the internet had been around to the extent it was around when the prequels came out, you'd have seen exactly the same stuff play out. And I think in 10 years' time, you're going to see what you're seeing with the sequels, because the sequels have a huge fan base and I meet them all the time, but they're all much younger than the people complaining on the internet about how much they didn't like. It's perfectly fine, if you don't like them, you don't like them. Everything's not for everyone. And I just think that these things are all generational and I think Battlestar Galactica said it best, 'this has all happened before, it will all happen again.
Herring’s comments stem from his intimate involvement in the production of the sequel trilogy, where he served as one of the primary performers operating BB-8 through a sophisticated combination of puppetry, remote control mechanisms, and on-set practical effects. The droid quickly became a standout character, endearing itself to audiences with its playful beeps, rolling movements, and loyal personality that complemented the human leads. Herring’s hands-on role gave him a unique vantage point not only on the technical challenges of creating such a memorable mechanical performer but also on the creative vision that shaped the films’ narrative direction under directors J.J. Abrams and Rian Johnson.
Throughout his career, Herring has contributed to several major film and television projects, but his work on BB-8 stands out as a career highlight that required months of rehearsal, design iteration, and real-time collaboration with visual effects teams to ensure the droid felt alive in every scene. In the recent interview, he reflected on the collaborative process behind BB-8’s creation, noting how the team aimed to blend cutting-edge technology with traditional puppeteering techniques reminiscent of earlier Star Wars creatures. This practical approach helped ground the character in a tangible way that resonated across the trilogy’s action sequences and quieter moments alike.
The actor also touched on the enduring appeal of BB-8 beyond the main films, mentioning ongoing interest in the character’s future within the expanding Star Wars universe. While the sequel trilogy wrapped up the Skywalker saga, Herring emphasized that the franchise’s storytelling continues to evolve, drawing from lessons of past installments. His generational view underscores a cyclical pattern in audience responses to new Star Wars entries, suggesting that time often reframes initial criticisms into appreciation as new viewers discover the stories.
Looking ahead, Star Wars is set to make a major return to theaters with The Mandalorian and Grogu arriving this May, bringing the popular Disney+ series characters to the big screen for the first time in a live-action adventure that promises to bridge the gap between the sequel era and new galactic tales. The film, directed by Jon Favreau, will reunite fans with the bounty hunter and his young charge in a story expected to explore uncharted corners of the galaxy. Additionally, Star Wars: Starfighter is scheduled for release next year, introducing an original storyline centered on high-stakes aerial combat and fresh heroes, further expanding the cinematic universe with innovative visuals and action set pieces.
Herring’s insights highlight the resilience of the Star Wars franchise, which has weathered similar debates across its prequel, original, and sequel chapters. By comparing the current discourse to past reactions, he reminds enthusiasts that passionate responses—positive or otherwise—are part of the series’ rich legacy.
As the saga moves forward with new theatrical entries, audiences can anticipate continued exploration of themes that have defined the franchise for decades, from legacy and redemption to the ever-present battle between light and dark. Herring’s balanced take encourages viewers to appreciate the diversity of perspectives that keep Star Wars a vibrant cultural phenomenon, ensuring its stories remain relevant for generations to come. Whether through the charm of BB-8 or the upcoming adventures in The Mandalorian and Grogu and Star Wars: Starfighter, the galaxy far, far away continues to captivate with its timeless storytelling.
